29 Comments

Well said, Jacob. Nice use of the term commissar. None of these tyrants were elected, but they want to be the arbiters of truth, misinformation, and “hate speech”. Fear is the weapon they use to reduce humans into sheep with lizard brains. We cannot let them win.

Expand full comment

Agreed. The Chevron doctrine, just thrown out, is similar in that a gov’t agency can make its own interpretation of a law or regulation, then act as judge and jury in upholding it. Gov’ts are trying to eliminate the general public’s power so only the elites can decide what is what. That is a significant step that an authoritarian gov’t will take to consolidate power.

Also notice that with free speech (and tax policy), the current administration is going around the constitution by enlisting the EU to make policy that affects US companies.

Expand full comment

The meaning of freedom and security -- Comparing life under "communism" and life under "capitalism" - it's less about ideology and more about financial anxieties and administrative restrictions.

https://substack.com/home/post/p-146812841?source=queue

Expand full comment

What is it that caused the wealthiest generation in history to turn against the values and freedoms that accelerated overall human welfare beyond anything previously imagined?

What do they imagine will better advance human welfare? Communism?

Expand full comment

Why assume they wish to advance overall human welfare? They clearly do not. Once you remove that confounding assumption, everything is perfectly clear.

Expand full comment

well said...

Expand full comment

“What is it that caused the wealthiest generation in history to turn against the values and freedoms”?

The boredom and meaninglessness of economic comfort.

Expand full comment

Captured K thru 12 schools and universities are the dynamite. Events such as Trump victory 2016, George Floyd overdose while resisting arrest, Hamas attack Oct 7th, and Harvey Weinstein type poster boys, are the fuse.

Expand full comment

Boredom and affluence

Expand full comment

Hmmm. Yes

Expand full comment

Thank you to all who are taking up these conversations, and especially to Michael and friends for their diligence and bringing community together on this topic.

Expand full comment

I hit the link for the hate monster. How utterly condescending of the Scottish government. It did kind of remind me of the big orange monster on bugs bunny cartoons.

Expand full comment

Right after the law was passed, the most frequently reported incident of "hate speech" was comments made by the Scottish First Minister, Humza Yousaf, in which he bemoaned the predominance of white leadership in Scotland, a country which is around 95% white.

Expand full comment

William Wallace is rolling over in his grave!

Expand full comment

It seems clear to those who have watched for a decade or two that Scotland is a complete mess. It is a train wreck of Orwellian nonsense.

Expand full comment
Jul 20·edited Jul 20

The notion of our collective infantilization -- that our "feewings" might be hurt by someone's choice of words or opinions-- struck me as a true and utter regression of our Western culture. Parents, teach your children well: love them tough, engender authentic resilience.

Expand full comment

Yes Yes YES'!!!!!! Thank you!

Expand full comment

FEAR is at the root of everything

Be afraid, be very afraid. That way we can manipulate you. That way we can get you to believe anything no matter how ludicrous. That way we can make you do what we want even if it makes no sense at all.

At this point it is Pavlov's dog. Bell ring, followed by reaction. Do not think, do not critique, just react. If you are a Democrat, you know that Trump is Evil and that JD is all that is evil about the Christian Right. If you are a conservative, you know that the Woke Left are behind every wrong in the world.

Meanwhile, "the Blob" does it's stuff unmolested. And since "The Blob" only believes in their own power and has no coherent world view it makes no sense.

Expand full comment

FYI - copied this article to FB and they removed it immediately and put me on notice. CIC is very much active and is basically destroying social media by eliminating free speech.

Expand full comment

I just tried to share on FB and it was immediately removed by FB!!!

Expand full comment

Why do you use FB at all?

Expand full comment

Wow. The censorship regime lives on.

Expand full comment

Below please find a link to a 2024 piece regarding disinformation written by Nina Jankowicz and published in Foreign Affairs.

Assuming you care to test it out by posting in FB, I wonder would they remove this as well. I’m guessing they won’t. I don’t use FB. If I did I would try this. No worries either way.

https://www.foreignaffairs.com/united-states/coming-flood-disinformation

Expand full comment

Europeans need to recall the courage of their forefathers in the recent past and fight this battle themselves.

Expand full comment

This is the best summary I have seen of the real existential threat we face as a "free" society. We are all distracted while they systematically dismantle the Bill of Rights.

Expand full comment

I tried sharing this article on facebook but it keeps being removed. Goes against their community standards. Wtf

Expand full comment

All ‘hate speech’ laws everywhere should be repealed. They are, as you say authoritarian and infantilising. Here’s my take on the Scottish government’s insanity. There’s been an election since then. So maybe it will improve a bit. But Labour seems to share the SNPs view that we’re all monsters in need of their benign guidance. https://open.substack.com/pub/lowstatus/p/its-grim-up-north?r=evzeq&utm_campaign=post&utm_medium=web

Expand full comment

Scotland seems to be turning into a dystopia.

Expand full comment

Thank you. And -- an interesting and related article:

The meaning of freedom and security -- Comparing life under "communism" and life under "capitalism" - it's less about ideology and more about financial anxieties and administrative restrictions.

https://substack.com/home/post/p-146812841?source=queue

Expand full comment